IMDb, TMDB, Rotten Tomatoes and Metacritic: How to Read Movie Ratings
A film is 7.8 on one site, 91 percent on another and 63 on a third. Which should you believe? The answer is that they measure different things. Once you know how each is built, you can use them together instead of being confused by them.
Audience averages: IMDb and TMDB
Both sites collect star ratings from registered users and show an average out of 10. TMDB, the database that powers the film information on PVR Info, uses a straightforward user vote average. IMDb applies a weighting method that is not fully public to limit manipulation. Because anyone can vote, audience scores reflect popular taste and can be swayed by fans.
Reading tip: look at the number of votes. A score of 8.5 from 200 votes is far less reliable than 7.9 from 200,000.
Rotten Tomatoes: a percentage of positive reviews
Rotten Tomatoes shows two percentages. The Tomatometer is the share of professional critics who gave a positive review. It is not an average score: a film where every critic gives a lukewarm 3 out of 5 can be 100 percent "fresh". The Audience Score shows the share of viewers who rated the film positively.
Metacritic: a weighted average
Metacritic converts critic reviews to a score from 0 to 100, gives more weight to major publications and averages them. It is harder to score high on Metacritic, so a 75 is considered strong and anything above 80 is "universal acclaim".
Why the scores disagree
- Different people: critics watch hundreds of films and often favour originality, while casual audiences favour entertainment.
- Different maths: a percentage of positive reviews and an average of scores are not the same thing.
- Fan voting: opening-week audience scores for franchise films or star vehicles often run high or low depending on fandom.
- Review bombing: organised campaigns of very low or very high votes can distort early numbers.
- Regional taste: Indian-language films may be reviewed by fewer international critics, so audience scores are more informative than critic aggregates.
A simple way to use them
- Start with the audience score for a quick feel, ignoring films with very few votes.
- Check the critic score for films that are artistic or unusual.
- If audience and critic scores differ a lot, read a review to see why. A film critics dislike but audiences love is often a crowd-pleaser; the reverse is often slow, difficult or challenging.
- Match the genre to your own taste. A 6.5 comedy you like beats an 8.0 drama you will not finish.
What ratings cannot tell you
They do not know your taste, your mood or your tolerance for violence. They also rarely capture how a film plays on a large screen with a crowd. Treat ratings as a filter for avoiding bad choices, not a guarantee of enjoyment.
About the ratings on PVR Info
The star ratings on our movie pages come from TMDB audience votes, and we show them only when a film has a meaningful number of votes. They are audience ratings, not our own reviews.